Which Is Better: Super Chewer BarkBox Or BULLYMAKE BOX?

Written by: Dr. Katy Nelson

March 7, 2019

If you have a toy-destroyer, you know your dog LOVES to rip, shred, thrash, and straight-up annihilate their toys. Sure, you have to clean up after the massacre, but it’s worth it knowing how much joy it brought them.

The thing is, it would be GREAT if those toys lasted just a little bit longer, don’t you think? BARK’s Super Chewer box and the BULLYMAKE BOX each cater to the expert gnaw-ers of the world, but which is the best fit for you and your pup?

What Comes In The Box?

The Super Chewer BarkBox comes with two fluff-free toys, two full-size bags of treats, and two meaty, all-natural chews.

The BULLYMAKE BOX includes 2-3 tough chew toys and 3-4 bags of all-natural treats.

Durability & Design

Durability is obviously important for tough-chewer pup parents. What goes INTO a toy is just as important as how it’s created, and versatility is always a must. With a little creativity, a chew toy is good for so much more than just chewing.

Super Chewer BarkBox Materials

Super Chewer boxes contain 100% fluff-free toys made primarily with strong rubber and nylon.

Designers used overmold technology in the “Secrets of the Rainfurrest” box to wrap rubber around “Ilana the Iguana”‘s nylon core in her mid-section. Combined with her bumpy scales and raised ridges, Ilana incorporates fun textures and different sensations while dogs gnaw away.

“Shuck That Corn” from the “Bark Slope Street Fair” box entices dogs to do more than just chew—it triples as a treat dispenser and tug toy, too. Crinkle husks and a rope “stalk” add additional elements for play, and with small treats or kibble placed inside, the challenge to free them gives this toy a longer lifespan.

When the vikings landed in the “Vikings of Valhowla” box, they brought the rubber “Treat Lock Tread Ball” with them. This ball takes treat toys to a new level by pairing them with Y-shaped treats that “lock in.” The studded top half of the ball introduced fun new textures, while the bottom experimented with a unique, durable rubber and bamboo blend.


BULLYMAKE BOX toys typically consist of durable nylon and rubber, and customers can opt to receive toys made with rope or ballistic material. The “Cherry Bomb” toy from the September 2017 box features multiple ways to play, and gets dogs tugging, fetching, chewing, and using their brains to retrieve treats from the dispenser.

BULLYMAKE boxes do not include toys that squeak, though they are sometimes infused with flavors like peanut butter or candy corn, and often double as a treat dispenser. The rubber BULLYMAKE “Cheeseburger,” for example, has a hollow space inside for hiding and dispensing your dog’s favorite treats.

For intense chewers, the super-tough nylon in the “XOXO” heart toy holds its own, designed with a textured pattern on the surface.

Replacement Policy

The term “indestructible” gets thrown around a lot when it comes to professional toy destroyers and humans fed up with picking up fluff. But what happens when a toy meets its inevitable end?

Super Chewer’s 100% Satisfaction Guarantee

If your dog shows that toy who’s boss, Super Chewer will replace it for free at any time, no questions asked. If your pup simply doesn’t care for a toy, reach out to the BarkBox Happy Team at [email protected] to find something that’ll have them jumping with joy.

BULLYMAKE BOX’s 14-Day Guarantee

When power chewers manage to tear through a BULLYMAKE toy, they’ll replace it within 14 days of receipt of shipment, provided you submit a photo of the toy and qualify for a replacement. They’ll also help your pup find a replacement for toys that just don’t get their tails wagging.

Treats & Chews

The meaty morsels and tasty tidbits to complement every playtime.

Super Chewer BarkBox Treats & Chews

All full-size bags of treats in the Super Chewer BarkBox get a personalized touch from the BarkBox designers; everything from the bag design to the shape of the treats themselves remain on-theme for that particular box. The all-natural treats are always 100% wheat, corn, and soy-free, and are made in the USA & Canada with domestic and imported ingredients.

These boxes also include two meaty chews, including anything from crunchy beef trachea to chewy turkey sausages.


BULLYMAKE designs and manufactures their bags of treats for each box in the USA, from BBQ Chicken and Apple to Beefy Biscuits.


Nothing is one-size-fits-all when it comes to dogs. They’re all individuals with particular likes and dislikes, and deserve to get exactly what they love.

Super Chewer Tailored Boxes

Allergy-friendly Super Chewer boxes exclude beef, chicken, and turkey. If your pup has other allergen concerns or general dislikes, just chat with the Happy Team to tailor your options.

Further customization, including all-toy boxes and toy tailoring, is coming very soon!

BULLYMAKE BOX Customization

BULLYMAKE caters to pups with allergies to beef, chicken, and grains. Dogs with severe allergies can choose a toys-only box, and have the option to choose toys with rope or ballistic material.


Your dog needs to be happy, but so does your wallet!

Super Chewer Pricing

Starts at $29/month for a 12-month subscription. You can also get a free month on any 6 or 12-month plan!


Starts at $31/month for a 12-month subscription.

How It Works

Get the gist from order to delivery of your first box.

Sign up for Super Chewer BarkBox

Step One: Choose your subscription! Choose a 12-month, 6-month, or monthly plan. Each box is a $45 value.

Step Two: Your first box ships immediately with subsequent boxes shipping on the 15th of every month.

Step Three: Celebrate #SuperChewer with the entire pack!


Step One: Pick your plan! Choose a 12-month, 6-month, 3-month, or monthly subscription.

Step Two: Your first box ships on the next business day with subsequent boxes shipping every 30 days thereafter.

Step Three: Rip open your box and give your pup’s chompers a serious job to do.

Long-lasting toys aren’t just about keeping your dog busy and working their mental muscles, they’re about having a BLAST! It’s time we embrace our tough chewers and give them a challenge worthy of their super-powered chompers. Sign up for Super Chewer or BULLYMAKE to give your pup the best monthly surprise!

Looking for tough dog toys? The Super Chewer box is made for pups who deserve a challenge – and for humans who are sick of throwing away destroyed toys five minutes after getting them. Plans start at $29/month and

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Written by: Dr. Katy Nelson

March 7, 2019

Nutritionist-crafted food for your dog's breed or mix.

Recipes designed for dogs' individuality



A themed collection of BARK-designed toys, treats, and chews.


A themed collection of BARK-designed toys, treats, and chews.