23 Heavy-Duty Dog Toys For Monster Chewers

Updated 3/15/19! So you're looking for the most durable dog toys for the monster chewer in your life... Do you know a dog who can burn through a chew toy faster than Usain Bolt burns up the track? Or that makes mincemeat out of home furnishings when they're alone? Either way, those dogs need tough toys, now. Here's a list of the top 23 heavy duty dog toys for your tough chewer....

1. The #1 Solution for the Toughest-Chewing Dogs: Super Chewer BarkBox

The Super Chewer BarkBox is made for pups who deserve a challenge—and for humans who are sick of throwing away destroyed toys five minutes after getting them. Plans start at $29/month with 2 toys, 2 treats, and 2 chews delivered to your door each month! PLUS, with this link you’ll get 1 month free on any 6 or 12-month plan!  

2. Bacon Benebone, $10-18

Flavored with bacon and designed to fit the contours of your dog's jaw, it's perfect for long chewing sessions. The three-pronged wishbone shape is made for gripping and the choice of three ends to chew.

3. Rubber And Nylon Toys

Haven't you heard? Rubber and nylon are the new plush. These sturdy materials make up some of the most exciting and durable dog toys, otherwise known as Super Chewer Toys. Karla Gnarly Cardinal BarkShop Super Chewer Toy Does your pup love the sound of squeakers, but tear through plush toys in seconds? Perhaps BARK's "Karla the Gnarly Cardinal" will make for a more worthy opponent. Made of durable natural rubber, this tough toy will entice your pup with its sensational squeaker, but also hold up to long lasting play. The rubber makes for an erratic bounce for fun games of fetch. Pit Bull with BarkBox Super Chewer Ilana the Iguana Made of both rubber and nylon, BARK’s "Ilana the Iguana" is tough and textured making it great for pups who like to chew and gnaw.

4. Bouncy Buddy Bone, $10

Chock full of "chompohydrates" and "rompoflavin," the PetSafe Buddy Bone offers all the chewlicious pleasure your dog requires. Made of a durable rubber bouncy ball and nylon bone that unscrews so you can add treat rings to the mix!

5. Peanut Butter Pawplexer, $15-18

Available in medium or large, the Pawplexer resists monster chewers of all sizes. Simple but strong and made of super tough nylon infused with real peanut butter, its center opening is perfect for inserting all kinds of treats and chews.

6. Benebone BARK Pretzel, $14-16

Skip the mustard and go straight for the bacon with this epically twisted toy. Its tantalizing grooves and curves make for a new & fun chewing experience that will last much longer than a soft pretzel.

7. Benebone Bacon Dental Chew, $11-13

The folks at Benebone really know what they're doing when it comes to unstoppable chewers. This bacon-flavored dental bone has prominent grooves to massage gums and help keep teeth clean, and its curved shape makes it easy to hold onto.

8. Orbee-Tuff Peace Sign Nook, $13

If your idea of peace is a crazy-tough toy sans squeaks, we've got just the ball for you. Its erratic bouncing is exciting enough, but squeeze a couple of your dog's favorite treats in the Nook's nooks and you'll be good to go.

9. The Best Stick Ever

While every dog loves a bone, some dogs require nothing less when it comes to play time chewing. If gnawing away is your pup's preferred play style, consider giving them a tough treat that can't be beat (at least, not without a good fight). Made with real maple wood and durable nylon, Benebone's Maplestick is both tougher and safer than a real stick. Great for games of fetch and long lasting chew time, the real maple wood gives this toy a little more give than traditional nylon toys. Available in size small, medium and large.

10. Treat Dispensers

Tough toys that also dispense treats are another great option for strong chewing pups. The treats make for a rewarding play time and also distract dogs from letting loose on the toys themselves. However, even if they choose to chew, these toys can handle it. BarkBox Shuck N Chuck Corn Cob Dog Toy Give your pup a smorgasbord of tough materials with BARK’s "Shuck n’ Chuck Corn Cob." This treat dispensing toy features a durable rubber cob, ballistic nylon rope, and crazy crinkle husks. Your dog won’t know where to chomp first. Oh wait, yeah they will. The treats! Pretty Cool Pine Cone BarkShop Dog Toy BARK's "Pretty Cool Pine Cone" is not only made of a special formula of rubber that’s great for power chewers, but can also hold and dispense a variety of yummy rewards including treats, peanut butter, or really anything your pup loves to snack on. You can even freeze it for scrumptious pupsicle fun.

11. Rope Toys

Give your chewer’s chompers a challenge with a game of tug of war! Your dog will go nuts for BARK’s "Oakley the Acorn." This tough toy is made of natural rubber with textures that your pup will love to gnaw on, and the durable rope is great for tugging and pulling.

12. Bully Sticks

Here's an all-natural, odor-free treat that your dog will love---and your nose will, too! They’re 100% digestible and made from American born and raised cattle (USDA certified). Plus, make them last even longer by wrapping one in a toy like this Veggout. steer stick

13. Diamond Plate Ball 

This American-made and non-toxic toy is covered with a durable diamond-plate pattern that makes for a good grip on your pup's sharp teeth. With a nice buoyant bounce, your dog will love playing fetch with this toy for hours on end. diamonplateball

14. Trachea

If you're looking for a natural chew and not a toy, these chews are great. They are hollow but tough, and will last a good few hours. Beef trachea are high in chondroitin and glucosamine which can help promote healthy joints in dogs. trachea

15. Octopus Retrieval Ball

This nifty toy is made of solid, super-sturdy natural rubber and will be quite the match for even the strongest doggy jaws. Available in both small and large, this brightly colored toy is easy to spot for outdoor play, and made for easy cleaning, too! octopus

16. Big Orange Ball

Made of natural rubber and tough polyester, this super-durable toy is perfect for your gentle (or not-so-gentle) giant. Gone are the days of your 140 lb beauty chasing a teeny tiny tennis ball. This bright and appropriately sized toy will be your big dog's new favorite. orange

17. Stogies Fetch Stick

For the fanciest of pups. This durable rope toy comes in two sizes and will have your pup eliciting a high class attitude. ropestick

18. Cow/Pig Ears

Delicious and crunchy, these are perfect for the chew-lovin' pup who prefers not to handle the tougher stuff. Get a slow-dried Half Pig Ear for your dog and he'll be sure to thank you... in 15 minutes after he's done his very important chewin' business. pigear

19. The Odin

A puzzle toy that contains treats for your mastermind pup to get out. This one is special because it's geometric in shape and can be connected with other Odin toys to increase the difficulty for your pup! odin

20. Himalayan Dog Chew

This chew is probably one of the longest lasting of all natural dog chews. Get a Himalayan Dog Chew holder from your local pet store to make this amazing chew last doubly long! the_g0lden_nugget

21. The Tizzi

Armed with a secret compartment you can stash with treats, this toy is perfect for fetch, tug-o-war, or even a game in the backyard pool. Super-durable and coated with bright, fun colors, it's made for the outdoors so your pup can easily spot, fetch, play, and repeat. tizzi

22. Elk Antlers

Perfect if you're looking for a natural chew with no greasy or stinky mess left behind. These are a great source of vitamins and minerals, such as calcium, zinc, manganese and potassium. These are also great for dental health, keeping tartar knocked down on teeth. antler

 23. Wild Wolf Wishbone

This 100% organic suede leather chew is super tough without being abrasive on your pup's teeth. Stuff it in your pup's stocking, and don't forget to get the other matching Wild Wolf toys, too! wishbone
Can't get enough? Sniff these related posts:

For more tough-chewing solutions, check out these articles!

What Comes in a Super Chewer Box? (With Photos of Real Dogs!) Which Is Better: Super Chewer BarkBox Or BULLYMAKE BOX? What Is A Dog Subscription Box For Heavy Chewers? What Are The Most Durable Dog Toys?

Hope Bobbitt

3 years ago

Get An Exclusive Look Inside Every Adventure-Filled Box!

Theme Reveal Newsletter Signup

Each month we'll send an email that shows the wild and adventurous theme of our newest Super Chewer box!